Games like Probably Stolen for shopkeepers with loose morals

Storage Hunter Simulator, Moonlighter and Papers, Please each cover a piece of what makes Probably Stolen fun: buy cheap, sell high, and check goods you should not trust. Here is what to play next, plus Roam flip-and-sell games.

What Probably Stolen is

Probably Stolen is a cyberpunk pixel-art shopkeeper sim by Questing Goose Studio, published by tinyBuild. It launched on Steam for PC on October 28, 2026. The studio says it sold more than 200,000 copies within hours, and its Steam peak passed 86,000 players at once, a record for tinyBuild.

You run a shop where a lot of the stock is not quite legal. You buy, inspect and resell goods, judge every customer (some of them work for Security), hide contraband from inspections and raids, and keep up with rent that only goes up. Its demo was one of the most played at Steam Next Fest in October 2026.

Shop and haggling sims

Storage Hunter Simulator. Raccoons Studio's game about bidding on storage units, sorting the junk and selling what is worth money.
Supermarket Simulator. Nokta Games' 2024 store sim. Stock shelves, set prices, run the till, grow the shop.
Moonlighter. Digital Sun's 2018 game: fight in dungeons by night, run a shop by day, and set prices by reading how customers react.
Potionomics. Voracious Games' 2022 potion shop where haggling plays out as a card battle.
Bid Wars. A mobile game about storage auctions and flipping what you find.

For the shady side

Half the fun of Probably Stolen is the risk. These games are about checking things and breaking rules on purpose.

Papers, Please. Lucas Pope's 2013 border checkpoint game. Inspect papers, catch smugglers, take or refuse bribes.
Thief Simulator. Noble Muffins' 2018 game where you case houses, steal goods and sell them on.

Roam games about buying and selling

Locker Flip (Roam). A storage-auction tycoon. Bid on the box, then find out what you won.
Forge Master (Roam). A blacksmith shop sim: take the order, fire the forge, get paid.
Eat the Customers (Roam). A shop sim with a twist. Stock the shelves, smile at the fish, then eat the fish.

Play it on Roam

Make your own shady shop game with Roam

Describe the shop, the customers and what happens if you get caught. Roam builds it, and you add rules by talking.

Try: "pawn shop on a space station, robots sell me stolen parts, haggle for every price, police raid if I get greedy"

Create it with Roam See Roam

Questions people ask

Is Probably Stolen on mobile?

No. It launched on PC through Steam. For a flipping game on the phone, try Bid Wars or Locker Flip on Roam.

Who made Probably Stolen?

Questing Goose Studio developed it and tinyBuild published it. It launched on Steam on October 28, 2026.

Is there a pawn shop game like Probably Stolen with auctions?

Storage Hunter Simulator is the closest. You bid on units, then sell what is inside.